[Thảo luận] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

[Hanakotoba]

Giờ đã cuối tháng 11, Moe game award 2012 cũng sắp khởi động. Nhân dịp này chúng ta hãy cùng điểm qua một vài tựa VN nổi bật trong năm nay và xem chúng sẽ thế nào khi so sánh với những tựa game nổi bật một năm trước đó.

Theo mình theo dõi thì những tựa nổi bật từ đầu năm tới giờ gồm:

1. Hatsuyuki Sakura
Hãng sản xuất: Saga Planet
EGS hiện tại: 84/100

Info

Kawano Hatsuyuki is a third-year student, one of the rare delinquents at his school. He reluctantly shows up in order to fulfill his graduation requirements.

It's December, and the first snow of the year has fallen.
In one lot of the old town, Hatsuyuki encounters a beautiful girl wearing a white dress. She's wandering the streets under the falling snow, in search of a rabbit.
A few days later, the girl in the dress - Sakura - transfers into his school.
To take Hatsuyuki along towards the last winter.

With the turn of the four seasons, 1095 days come to an end.
Soon winter will pass, and spring will arrive.
Embracing memories of snow that never accumulated, the youth stands perfectly still.

From the first snow (Hatsuyuki) to the cherry blossoms (Sakura), congratulations on your graduation.

2. Kono Oozora ni, Tsubasa wo Hirogete
Hãng sản xuất: Pulltop
EGS hiện tại: 84/100

Info

Aoi returned to his hometown of Kazegaura where a gentle breeze blows through the streets, having lost his direction in life. On the hill lined with windmills, he met a wheelchair-ridden girl Kotori and watched the gliders overhead in awe. With his childhood friend Ageha in tow, they resurrect the soaring club in order to fulfill a childhood dream: to fly on a paper airplane.

3/ Tsuki ni Yorisou Otome no Sahou
Hãng sản xuất: Navel
EGS hiện tại: 84/100

Info

Coming from a prestigious family, that didnt want him, in the financial world, Yuusei had been home-schooled strictly and sheltered all his life. Even though he excelled at everything, it was his dream to live a life of a commoner. One day his chance came and he changed his identity to Asahi and entered Fairy Girl’s School, which specializes in female fashion for the rich. As part of his plan, he became the maid of his classmate Runa and worked at her home Sakura-yashiki. Also living there were a proud exchange student from Switzerland, Ursule, a Yamato Nadeshiko, Mizuho, and his childhood Minato, who had feelings for him and was also the only one who knew his true identity. With her help, will he be able to manage his double life in the school and his new home?

4/ Grisaia no Meikyuu
Hãng sản xuất: Frontwing
EGS hiện tại: 83/100

Info

Roughly a year after his arrival at Mihama, Yuuji makes the unexpected decision to pursue promotion within CIRS. The action resumes with Yuuji in a meeting with JB at "corporate HQ," discussing the documents he submitted for review as a part of the promotion process - said documents pertaining to none other than Yuuji's own past. Meanwhile, back at the dorm, the girls find themselves unwittingly following along after Sachi and Makina restore the shredded rough draft of said documents.

The irony, of course, being that prominent figures in Yuuji's past may just be continuing to exert their influence upon the present...

5. D.C III ~ Da Capo ~
Hãng sản xuất: Circus
EGS hiện tại: 82/100

Info

The sakura that bloomed year-round are now a thing of the past and Hatsunejima is now known as an island that shows that beauty of each season.

Kiyotaka is a second-year student at Kazami Gakuen who is part of the news club along with the school idol Rikka, his imouto-like osananajimi Himeno, his mixed-race cousin Charles, hard-working kouhai who skipped a grade and is in his class Sara, and energetic in spirit but weak in body Aoi.

Unlike in the past, there are no more mysterious things happening on the island. That was until one winter day when the sakura began to bloom. All the news club members got a message on their cell phones telling them to do something at a promised place when the sakura begins to bloom. They couldn’t make out the rest of the message, but are surprised that it was dated 1951. Rikka was extremely curious about the message and the sudden blooming of the sakura, so she called on everyone to solve the mystery with her.

6. Harumade, Kururu.
Hãng sản xuất: Sumikko Soft
EGS hiện tại: 81/100

Info

For some reason, the protagonist ended up spending his spring break with four girls in a remote area that had no wireless reception and didn’t even have a convenience store. There was only a school building that seems to be on the verge of closure, a large dormitory that looked like a hot spring hotel and a chimney that stretched up to the sky as far as the eyes could see. He thought that he would just spend some peaceful days here, but that’s when one of the girls Shizuka declared that they will make this place his harem, and started stripping in front of him in his bewilderment.

7. Soukoku no Arterial
Hãng sản xuất: Eushully
EGS hiện tại: 79/100

Info

Shuuya lives with his younger sister Mirai and attends Academy Tengyou Daini. However, their peaceful days come to an abrupt end as their world is taken over by an alternate world called Waibin Sekai – one where angels and demons battle each other and monsters called ‘creators’ roam freely. The students are forced to decide to ally with the angels, side with the demons or do neither. No matter which choice they make, they would be hard pressed to survive in this dangerous world.

8. fortissimo EXS//Akkord:nächsten Phase
EGS hiện tại: 79/100
Hãng sản xuất: Lacryma

Info

Reiji is a typical student on the remote southwest island of Tsukuyomi-jima. However, due to an unexpected event where his life was in danger, he awakened as the 13th magical summoner. After summoning the spirit and magical superweapon Sakura, she gifts him with the special ability ‘Da Capo,’ which allows him to summon anyone who he met in the past 24 hours or reverts items back to its previous state (up to 24 hours ago). Now they must participate in a battle they cannot avoid.

9. Otome ga Tsumugu Koi no Canvas
EGS hiện tại: 78/100
Hãng sản xuất: Ensemble

Info

Shin was instructed to record a TV program as usual by his sister Hatora, who was a famous artist. When he turned on the screen, he saw a photo of himself dressed as a girl being auctioned for lots of money. Hatora quipped that next time she’ll take a nude photo of him. Sensing danger, he ran away from home… only to realize later that he was still dressed as a girl.

He ended up in front of the art gallery and a seemingly rich girl Rena asked why he was there so late at night. Mistaken for a student at the nearby girls-only art school Oukou Gakuen, he was taken inside to observe a bunch of paintings being brought into the gallery. Suddenly, he noticed some thieves and ended up getting taken hostage. After being saved by Rena’s bodyguard Chiharu, he thought he was free to go… but then Rena ushered him into the waiting limousine and took him to her mansion!

Rena questioned him how he had known that the paintings were fake and demanded to know his name, upon which he replied Mizuki, which was his surname. With the help of the head maid Akie, he managed to not have his identity fully blown. Then Rena presented him with a school uniform and told him that she had signed him up at Oukou Gakuen after hearing that he didn’t attend school. He will also serve as her maid. Unable to return home, how will Shin…, no, Mizuki fare in this new setting!?

10. Supipara - Alice the magical conductor. STORY #01 - Spring Has Come !
Hãng sản xuất: Minori
EGS hiện tại: 77/100

Info

springtime with the sakura in full bloom. Yukinari returned to his hometown of Kamakura and was welcomed by his older relative Sakura (in a maid outfit). He had wished for a peaceful life, but it’s always lively being surrounded by the sharp-tongued half-blooded Hotaru and the lazy anime-loving witch Alice at the coastal school. Due to some persuasion by his friend, he ended up on the committee for the school beauty contest. With all the contestants (heroines) having their own peculiarities, there’s plenty of enjoyable events (and troubles).

 

Trong khi đó top VN của năm 2011 gồm:

1. White Album 2 ~closing chapter~
Hãng sản xuất: leaf
EGS hiện tại: 95/100

Info

As if to match the guitar I play in the afternoon music classroom,
as if to match the piano someone plays in the next room,
the pure singing voice from the rooftop connects the three disconnected melodies.

It all started in such a day in late autumn.
At that time, someone fell in love.

Everyone was doing their best. Everyone pushed on. Everyone was intent and honest…
We formed a bond and obtained a previous moment.
That’s why someone fell in love. A love that was too late, a love that shouldn’t have occurred.

And then comes winter. The falling snow covers all sins.
And spring eventually comes, melting the snow and imposing all punishments.

2. Aiyoku no Eustia
Hãng sản xuất: August
EGS hiện tại: 85/100

Info

After the surface of the world broke down, the city of Novus Aether floats in the sky, thanks to the prayers of the Holy Maiden. Years ago, when the Holy Maiden's prayer was interrupted, an incident known as the "Gran Forte" occurred, causing a portion of the land to fall and split the lower city into two, separated by a cliff.

In time, the lowest layer became the dwelling of all kinds of low-lives, people who lost much of their former lives during the "Gran Forte", becoming known as the "Prison". However, a contagious disease which causes people to grow wings has spread throughout the city, and a unit has been formed to deal with these people swiftly.

In this "Prison" resides Caim Astraea, a freelance ex-assassin who does odd jobs for his friends for money, refusing jobs that require him to kill people. During one request, Caim finds a girl who contracts the wing-disease, enveloped in a light that reminds Caim of the “Gran Forte” years ago...

3. Grisaia no Kajitsu
Hãng sản xuất: Frontwing
EGS hiện tại: 83/100

Info

Mihama Academy - on the surface, a closed learning environment established to nurture students who find themselves at odds with the world around them; in actuality, an orchard-cum-prison built to preserve fruit that has fallen too far from its tree.

Whatever the circumstances behind its establishment, Mihama Academy is at present home to five female students, all with their own reasons for "enrollment." For better or worse, each girl has established a routine obliging of her current situation; life moves at an idle, yet accommodating pace within the walls of Mihama.

Yet with the arrival of the institute's first male student, the nearly preposterously opaque Kazami Yuuji, the students at Mihama begin to fall out of step with their predetermined rhythms. Will Yuuji prove to be the element the girls around him needed to take hold of their lives once more, or will the weight of their pasts prove too steep a wall to overcome?

And in the first place, just who is Kazami Yuuji? While the true nature of the "job" he is wont to alight to at the most haphazard of moments remains shrouded in secrecy, one thing is for certain - his encroachment upon the quiet orchard known as Mihama Academy will prove itself momentous in one way or another. And of course, one cannot discount the possibility that perhaps Yuuji himself carries the weightiest past of any of the students...

4. Irotoridori no Sekai
Hãng sản xuất: Favourite
EGS hiện tại: 83/100

Info

When he was a child, Yuuma received a special power from the “translucent magician”, Shinku. Just by touching someone with his hand, he is able to cure all of their wounds in return for some of his memories. In the furthestmost port town of Kazatsugahama, there is a link to a another world hidden in the basement of the Arashiyama-sou dormitory. Within this world he lives his life like a dream. One night while the full moon shone brightly, a girl descended from the sky. “Mister magician, please save me.”

5. Kamidori Alchemy Meister
Hãng sản xuất: Eushully
EGS hiện tại: 87/100

Info

In the Setetori region of the southern part of the Raulbhach continent lies the Mikelti Kingdom, and amongst the seven major cities of this region is the workshop city of Yuidora. This is where a young orphan named Wilfred lives, pursuing his dream of becoming an alchemist. However, soon after gaining his license he gets entangled with three girls with differing personalities and goals, and he soon agrees to hire them as his guards in order to help each other out. Like this, Wil begins his life as an alchemist, surrounded by the ever growing group of his allies as he follows his parents' footsteps in becoming a great alchemist.

 

Mình chưa đọc phần lớn trong các bộ release năm nay nhưng theo phản hồi của /jp/ và các bảng xếp hạng thì có vẻ như năm nay chưa thật sự có bộ nào đạt được đỉnh cao như bộ ba Eustia - Grisaia - Eustia làm được như ngoái. Tsuki Sahou, Konosora và Hatsusaku là những VN hay nhưng để gọi là rất hay và rất xuất sắc thì có lẽ chưa đủ tầm.

Lưu ý là list ở trên là list tổng hợp của cá nhân mình chứ không phải bảng xếp hạng nào cả. Vì vậy các câu cứ thoải mái đưa ra ý kiến và list riêng của mình nhé. [/tab][/tabs]

 

[Shinmyou]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

Chưa chơi white album nên không biết chứ Aiyoku no Eustia (đọc năm ngoái) và Grisaia mới (đọc cách đây vài tháng), thì đúng hàng năm nay không so sánh được
PS: Grisaia no Meikyuu đưa nhầm link rồi kìa hoa

 

[Keyne]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

đánh giá thế nào giờ, khi mà năm nay chưa tử tế chơi được 1 cái VN nào = )

 

[UchihaBeast]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

mình ko bik sao chứ đối với mình thì hàng năm ngoái Aiyoku được nhưng năm nay thì mình ấn tưởng nhất là bộ fortissimo và arterial với do chơi ít hơn mấy bác nên em xin coi như ko so sánh

 

[delacroix01]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

EXS thì mới chơi hết trial nên chưa rõ 2 route còn lại ra sao, nhưng nhìn mớ new CG thì nhiều tấm muốn tặng La'cryma 1 cái middle finger vì cái chất lượng. Route của Sakura (bên EXA) thì hồi đầu viết tốt, có điều mấy battle về sau cũng niềm tin nhiều quá nên mất chất đi. Hatsuyuki thì vẫn giữ nguyên quan điểm vì thoại quá hãm và phải tới phân nửa số heroine là ko ưa nổi. Đáng giá nhất thì có cái OST đỉnh, nhưng cho vào game khác thì hợp hơn vì nó quá overdramatic với 1 cái VN như vậy.

 

[Oboku-sama]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

Tsugumu no Canvas thấy hơi bất ngờ, mình đọc cái này cốt truyện cũng chỉ tầm trung trung mà sao điểm cao thế nhỉ Được cái là ko quá nhảm và cliche như các moe-ge trap đồng lọai nhưng ko biết tại sao điểm nó cao thế?

 

[Hanakotoba]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

^ 78 chỉ là mức điểm khá, có phải cao lắm gì đâu cậu?

EXS thì mới chơi hết trial nên chưa rõ 2 route còn lại ra sao, nhưng nhìn mớ new CG thì nhiều tấm muốn tặng La'cryma 1 cái middle finger vì cái chất lượng. Route của Sakura (bên EXA) thì hồi đầu viết tốt, có điều mấy battle về sau cũng niềm tin nhiều quá nên mất chất đi. Hatsuyuki thì vẫn giữ nguyên quan điểm vì thoại quá hãm và phải tới phân nửa số heroine là ko ưa nổi. Đáng giá nhất thì có cái OST đỉnh, nhưng cho vào game khác thì hợp hơn vì nó quá overdramatic với 1 cái VN như vậy.

Dòng EXA mình chưa chơi nên không biết nhưng thấy bên EGS nó đánh giá mấy bản đầu chỉ trên trung bình tí à (5x - 6x/100). XD
Không phải do nó all age nhé do Da Capo IIII hay Rewrite cũng all age đó thôi XD

 

[bestfriends_0705]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

Nhiều VN bị sai link nhé bạn.
Chưa chơi được cái nào trong đống đó >"<

 

[Maou-sama]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

Sao cái description của Soukoku ,fortissimo EXS và Supipara lại giống hệt nhau thế thím Hoa

springtime with the sakura in full bloom. Yukinari returned to his hometown of Kamakura and was welcomed by his older relative Sakura (in a maid outfit). He had wished for a peaceful life, but it’s always lively being surrounded by the sharp-tongued half-blooded Hotaru and the lazy anime-loving witch Alice at the coastal school. Due to some persuasion by his friend, he ended up on the committee for the school beauty contest. With all the contestants (heroines) having their own peculiarities, there’s plenty of enjoyable events (and troubles).

Cả list trên chơi mỗi Soukoku và fortissimo EXS ,thế nên ko dám ý kiến ,sợ ăn gạch

 

[delacroix01]

Re: [Discussion] Top Visual Novel 2012 vs top Visual Novel 2011?

Dòng EXA mình chưa chơi nên không biết nhưng thấy bên EGS nó đánh giá mấy bản đầu chỉ trên trung bình tí à (5x - 6x/100). XD
Không phải do nó all age nhé do Da Capo IIII hay Rewrite cũng all age đó thôi XD

Mấy site rating nói chung chả cái nào tin được cả. fortissimo công nhận plot hole khá nhiều, bù lại dialogue viết rất tự nhiên + mấy đoạn battle ở common route đọc rất khá, gái gú moe nữa. Chưa kể khoản voice acting và nhạc thì cái này thuộc hàng khủng chứ chả chơi đâu. Phần voice đảm bảo ngon hơn DCIII đấy