I see so many games mentioned that I need to try still! I mostly play otome games, but I love all visual novels! My favorites right now are: All three of Cheritz's games (Nameless is my number one), Second Reproduction, Tokimeki Memorial Girl's Side, and Doki Doki Literature Club. I am playing Collar x Malice right now and it might be added to this list, it's got a very good story so far.