Definitely Nameless. I love the half of the characters and art but the main plot too salty for my taste. Having the heroine who in love (and may have sex) with the guy then she remember nothing and continue did it with other guys? No!
Which Otome games do you both love & dislike?
- Thread starter EdgeyBoi
- Start date
ChiharuHanayagi
Illegal Member
Black Wolves Saga
So many abuse toward Fiona, so many blood, so less romance, yet the story is so damn good
So many abuse toward Fiona, so many blood, so less romance, yet the story is so damn good
Ok, just to revive this thread, let me share my experience with Hakuoki
Pros:
+ Befitting VA
+ Good remake, i.e. Kyoto Winds & Edo Blossoms
+ Likeable female NPCs
+ Moderate focus on romance
+ KW & ED have Sanan's route. He is bae~ <3. Overall, the quality of the remake is holistically impressive w.r.t. art, plot, character & romance development.
Cons (mostly w.r.t. Demons of the Fleeting Blossoms BC the remakes manage to reduce these pitfalls):
- Very annoying MC in DoTFB - all bark, no bite, unrealistic, passive, docile, hypocritical
- Boring info-dump. I think the plot is poorly developed for a historical fantasy.
I don't mind history, but at least devs should have the courtesy to go beyond event & character report in the narration.
Moreover, the fantasy element of demons are poorly developed for the lame excuse of impure bloodline and mixed marriages with humans.
- I know many other gamers manage to connect with the Shinsengumi, but I just can't. I feel exactly like how Kazuma said at the end of his route that they gave their lives away uselessly for their ideals.
- Abrupt costume change. It somehow grated on my nerves a lot, especially because I played Edo Blossoms prior to DoTFB, which has nice transition and explanation for most events.
- Very poor development and absolution of Koudou. In Kazuma's route, Kaoru totally disappeared.
Generally, I sometimes wonder why I was wasting my time playing both versions. Probably, I adore Sanan so much that I want to find all the evidence that other fans used to trash him.
Pros:
+ Befitting VA
+ Good remake, i.e. Kyoto Winds & Edo Blossoms
+ Likeable female NPCs
+ Moderate focus on romance
+ KW & ED have Sanan's route. He is bae~ <3. Overall, the quality of the remake is holistically impressive w.r.t. art, plot, character & romance development.
Cons (mostly w.r.t. Demons of the Fleeting Blossoms BC the remakes manage to reduce these pitfalls):
- Very annoying MC in DoTFB - all bark, no bite, unrealistic, passive, docile, hypocritical
- Boring info-dump. I think the plot is poorly developed for a historical fantasy.
I don't mind history, but at least devs should have the courtesy to go beyond event & character report in the narration.
Moreover, the fantasy element of demons are poorly developed for the lame excuse of impure bloodline and mixed marriages with humans.
- I know many other gamers manage to connect with the Shinsengumi, but I just can't. I feel exactly like how Kazuma said at the end of his route that they gave their lives away uselessly for their ideals.
- Abrupt costume change. It somehow grated on my nerves a lot, especially because I played Edo Blossoms prior to DoTFB, which has nice transition and explanation for most events.
- Very poor development and absolution of Koudou. In Kazuma's route, Kaoru totally disappeared.
Generally, I sometimes wonder why I was wasting my time playing both versions. Probably, I adore Sanan so much that I want to find all the evidence that other fans used to trash him.
Like she only talk when there's option.. I mean, i know she's amnesia, but that doesn't mean too quiet like that..
I can't really particularly name them since I haven't really played much and just relied on CGs heavily. If I do play some, I usually don't bother with the story lmao... So I can specify some settings and genres that I mostly avoid that probably apply to some Otoge:
Love: Smut, Comedy, Beautiful Art, Aggressive Female Lead, Psychological, 3P
Hate: Supernatural, Historical, Sci-Fi, School
Love: Smut, Comedy, Beautiful Art, Aggressive Female Lead, Psychological, 3P
Hate: Supernatural, Historical, Sci-Fi, School